Cast Iron Pipes

Cast iron pipes have an incredible lifespan, with many lasting up to 100 years. However, cast iron plumbing in millions of homes in South Florida have failed in less than 25 years due to extreme weather and environmental factors. The cost for cast iron pipe repair or pipe replacement can cost tens of thousands of dollars, and some insurance companies have denied paying for the repairs. 

Cast iron pipes have been a key piping material for more than a century due to its affordability and durability. However, with the introduction of PVC pipe, cast iron has seen a decline in use, as PVC piping tends to be more cost-effective and longer lasting.

Yet, around 76 million American homes still rely on cast iron plumbing. Houses built between the 1920s and 1940s are nearing the end of their cast iron pipes’ life expectancy, with some experiencing water damage or pipe failures in as little as 25 years.

In Southern Florida, homes with cast iron plumbing built as recently as 1975 are experiencing failures more frequently than anywhere else. This has led to expensive, unexpected repair bills for homeowners.

What Causes Early Cast Iron Pipes to Failure? 

Approximately 2.5 million homes in Florida have experienced early cast iron pipe failure. The combination of high humidity and salt-rich soil is believed to speed up the deterioration of cast iron plumbing, resulting in early pipe failure compared to other regions.

This can create a “double whammy,” as the pipes start corroding from the outside while the water and sewer gasses corrode it from the inside.

A clogged drain often signals the start of pipe failure. Water backing into the sink and toilets flushing more slowly are common signs of corrosion. However, there are other signs that cast iron pipes may be creating an unsafe environment. 

Signs of Cast Iron Pipe Failure:

• Leaks 

• Odors 

• Drain or sewer backup 

• Mold growth 

• Discolored water 

• Infestations of insects or rodents 

• Unusual puddles or excessive plant growth in the lawn

Drain pipes, particularly cast iron ones, often corrode at the bottom first. This can create build up and tiny leaks inside the pipes, obstructing the water flow. Water from exterior pipe leaks can erode the soil and lead to small sinkholes.

Cast Iron Pipe Replacement Costs

Pipe replacement, especially when dealing with old cast iron pipe, can be costly. Cast iron plumbing replacement estimates often fall between $10,000 and $30,000, depending on the area you live and the plumbing company you hire. This can escalate into a significant home remodeling project.

Some homeowners have faced expenses ranging from $50,000 to $150,000 when factoring in the costs of replacing floors, walls, and concrete due to cast iron pipe repair. The costs are more for larger structures like condominiums and commercial buildings. 

Beyond just replacing the cast iron pipes, other potential issues can arise, including: 

• The first sign of an exterior leak may be an unexpectedly high water bill. 
• Purchasing a home with cast iron plumbing could result in difficulty obtaining homeowners insurance. Certain companies won’t insure the property unless the cast iron piping system is replaced.
• Insurance providers have, at times, been criticized for refusing claims or not fully covering water damage costs. They might require you to report water damage within a strict time frame. Additionally, some may limit their payout amounts as low as $2,000.

Does Insurance Cover Cast Iron Pipes? 

Whether your homeowner’s insurance covers cast iron pipes largely depends on the specific terms and conditions of the policy, the cause of the damage, and the insurance company’s view on wear and tear vs. sudden incidents.

1. Wear and Tear vs. Sudden Incidents: Insurance typically covers sudden and unexpected damages. For instance, if a cast iron sewer pipe bursts due to a sudden event, your insurance may cover it. However, if the cast iron plumbing deteriorates over time due to normal wear and tear or lack of maintenance, insurance is less likely to cover the repair or replacement.
2. Old Homes: Homes that are several decades old and still have the original cast iron piping might face challenges with insurance claims. Some insurance companies view old cast iron pipes as a known risk, and may exclude them from coverage or require them to be replaced as a condition of providing insurance.
3. Insurance Exclusions: Some insurance policies have specific exclusions related to cast iron pipes, especially in regions where problems with these pipes are common.
4. Endorsements: Some policies offer endorsements or additional coverage options for plumbing systems, including cast iron pipes. Homeowners should check if they have such an endorsement or consider adding one.
5. Claims & Reporting: Some insurance providers have strict timelines for reporting water damage, and may cap payments for plumbing-related claims.
6. Home Inspection and Disclosures: If you are buying a home, any known issues with cast iron pipes should be disclosed. It could be difficult to get insurance to cover pre-existing issues.

To determine if your insurance covers cast iron pipe damage or replacement, you want to review your policy documents carefully and consult with an insurance agent or representative. If you’re purchasing a home, consider a plumbing inspection specifically focused on the type of piping and its condition.

Lastly, if you’re in an area with prevalent cast iron pipe issues (like parts of Florida), it’s even more critical to review your policy and discuss coverage specifics with your insurance provider.

Cast Iron Pipe Maintenance

In order to extend the lifespan of your cast iron pipes, it’s important to be mindful of what goes down the drain. The inner surface of cast iron plumbing can easily trap items such as feminine products and wet wipes and—even if they’re labeled flushable—leading to clogs and accelerated deterioration.

Stay away from harsh drain cleaners, as they can cause corrosion in cast iron piping. Opt for enzyme-based drain cleaning products instead.

If you’re considering purchasing an older home, apart from the usual home inspection, it may be wise to hire a plumber to check the cast iron drain pipe and other plumbing structures. While visible pipes may be updated with PVC piping, those entrenched in or underneath concrete could still be made of cast iron.

Additionally, you should consider investing in a pipe inspection before starting any major home renovations. This can prevent unexpected costs from a damaged pipe right as you’re about to invest in other areas of the home. These inspections are oftentimes very as affordable, and can save you from hefty repair bills down the road.

References